The basis.

Council Manager Form of Government.

The Manager
A city manager is appointed by the city council. In theory, the council makes policy and the manager sees that those policies are carried out. However, the manager and city bureaucrats may have been responsible for suggesting the policy in the first place, thus the city manager often does make policy and sets general directions behind the scenes through his or her influence over the council.

The Mayor
The mayor’s job is largely ceremonial. She presides over the council, and represents the city in various ways, but has no real power except as a member of the council.

Advantages
The central advantage of having a city manager is that he gives full time professional management to city business. In most cities, the council and the mayor are really part time amateurs.

Power
Certainly the office of mayor is an ideal platform for proclaiming need for change. However, mayors who come to office with high hopes of accomplishing great things soon collide with a few unexpected realities of public life. They may be surprised by their lack of real power. They learn how many things are not up to them to decide, and how many boards they must go through to make changes. They find that bureaucrats often arm themselves with political support, in excess of the mayors own.  Mayors discover that things they want to accomplish means changing things, but change means colliding with every interest satisfied with the status quo.

Influence
Why are city councils so docile in the face of city managers and agency heads? Councils routinely enact the policy recommendations of administrators, generally without much deliberation and without inserting many changes. Because many of these things are detailed, complex and require specialized knowledge to simply understand what is going on. A city council cannot possibly know as much as the experts and bureaucrats working on these projects. They must rely on the experts to supply the information to them. Otherwise they will bumble into stupid decisions that may prove very costly.

Another reason is that city council members are often poorly paid. Most time that they can afford to spend on city business is often taken up with routine. Most city councils meet once a week, and by the time they have dealt with the mundane and miscellany the meeting is nearly over. Little time is left for pondering the obscurities of large issues.

(An overview of parts of chapter 10, State & Local Politics, Robert S. Lorch.)  

30 July 2007 | Life | Comments

One Response to “The basis.”

  1. 1 Jerry 1 August 2007 @ 11:25 am

    It sounds as though there are no real checks and balances with this form of local government?

    I thought that was the job of the City Commissioners to inform themselves, listen to their public and properly oversee and direct the City Manager and his or her local bureacrats?

    If the local politicians cannot or will not perform these functions what is there purpose?

    JT

Leave a Reply

  1.  
  2.  
  3.  

Recent Comments:

  • Carl Let the spanking of the asses begin.
  • Lance Seems the Tribune has engaged agent provocateurs to...
  • Ed McKnight The first time I met with Colleen last year,...
  • Mary Jolley 500,000.00 was the Oct. 2004 commission...
  • firefly I find it troubling that on 3/2/07, the Assistant...

Close To Home

Archives

Pages

Categories

Meta

July 2007
M T W T F S S
« Jun   Aug »
 1
2345678
9101112131415
16171819202122
23242526272829
3031